We reserve the right to substitute cheese of equal value according to availability if necessary.
Please select your cheeses below and then click the Add button. All cheeses come in 1/2 lb blocks. Minimum order size is 2 lbs.
We use a vegetable-based rennet, so all cheeses are suitable for vegetarians.
Gift Certificate For more information about our gift certificates, please click here.
Apple Cheddar - Seasonal Bits of apple soaked in hard cider, gives this sharp cheddar a tangy bite. This seasonal cheese pairs well with dry champagne, lagers or light beers.
Asiago Aged 9-10 months, our brown-waxed Asiago is moister than traditional Asiagos, allowing it not only to be grated but savored on its own. For those who enjoy the rich and nutty flavor of Parmesan and Asiago, but not the hardness. Think pasta, think olive oil, think bruscetta, think red wine.
Asiago - Peppercorn Whole peppercorns, ginger and garlic add exceptional flavor to our already rich and nutty Asiago. Wonderful to grate in your favorite dishes or to slice and enjoy on its own.
Awe-Brie White mould rind. Smooth, creamy texture and distinct flavor.
Barren Co. Bleu It has a firm yet springy blue-veined interior with a tangy, slightly acidic, ripe flavor. It’s our “Stilton Wannabe”. The perfect after-dinner cheese course, and pairs well with fruits and nuts.
Cheddar - Horseradish All the deep tanginess of horseradish, without the spice, in our creamy mild white cheddar. Pairs perfectly with all meats.
Cheddar - Tomato Basil Bursting with basil and, more subtly, sun-dried tomato, this popular cheese offers loads of fresh flavor in every bite. (A little goes a long way alone, or cut into a cream sauce for pasta or fish.)
Cheddar - White The perfect balance of robust flavor and rich taste, without harsh sharpness or dryness.
Colby Loved for its unending uses, our Farmhouse Colby is extra creamy, fresh, with just a hint of sweetness. Colored with natural annatto seed.
Colby - Chipotle Loved for its unending uses, our Farmhouse Colby is extra creamy, fresh, with just a hint of sweetness, with the added flavor of chipotle. Colored with natural annatto seed.
Gouda - Aged Try the more sophisticated and elaborate flavor of our aged gouda.
Gouda - Bleu The sweet, creamy texture of Gouda accented by the tanginess of Rougefort.
Gouda - Cumin Seed Cumin seed is added to our authentic Gouda giving it an earthy flavor and elegant appearance.
Gouda - Mild Evident in its delicate and satiny texture, never "mushy" like processed versions. Mild, buttery undertones.
Gouda - Smoked Deep, hickory flavor imparts a smokey essence.
Havarti Luscious. All the decadent cream of a Havarti with a hint of tanginess that will surprise and delight you.
Havarti - Garden Herb Robust, yet not overpowering flavors of chive, shallot, and dill give fresh and dramatic color and flavor to our original.
KY Bleu Distinctive soft, creamy flavor as it eases into the palette and blossoms into fullness
KY Rose A lighter bleu cheese - with heavy butter and cream notes up front, middle notes of pecan and finishes with a citrus kind of snap
Monterey Jack A very mild, pure, but rich cheese.
Monterey Jack - Garlic Paprika While paprika gives this version its exciting color, it's the garlic that gives it its taste. Still rich in texture, this Jack is for those who enjoy plenty of garlic flavor.
Monterey Jack - Jalapeno Speckled with medium-spiced red and green jalapeno peppers, giving just enough spice to the creamy original.
Nena Rich and creamy Tomme style cheese. Made from our double cream Awe-Brie curds - firmer texture
Norwood Our version of Gruyere. It has a nutty, slightly sweet taste with complex musty and mushroom notes. Wonderful to eat on its own, and is delicious when used in a fondue.
St. Jerome It’s washed rind is smooth and leathery. The cheese is pale yellow in color and has a full, robust flavor with depth in the back of the palette. While creamy and butter-like, it is firm enough for slicing.
Swiss Our unique Jarlsberg-style Swiss with a nutty, buttery taste and honey undertones. A surprisingly soft texture, never dry or too bitter, with an exceptional depth of flavor.
Ted Old World Style Cave Aged Cheddar
2033 Thomerson Park Rd | Austin, KY 42123 | Phone: (888) 571-4029 | Fax: (270) 434-3879